Let’s Smash the Debate: Homemade Burger or Smash Burger?

The Reddit community debates whether a homemade burger qualifies as a smash burger. Read on to find out!

Users on Reddit’s food community recently engaged in a fiery debate over a homemade burger that sparked controversy and comedy alike. Here’s the scoop:

Summary

  • Reddit users discuss the authenticity of a homemade burger being labeled as a smash burger.
  • Comments range from humorous observations to serious critiques.
  • Debate centers on the technique and appearance of smash burgers.

The Great Smash Burger Debate

Recently, user pkragthorpe shared a picture of a burger proclaiming it as a ‘smash burger.’ However, the community quickly pointed out discrepancies, with comments like ‘Looks like a normal burger to me,’ and ‘No lace not smash.’

Smashing Misunderstandings

Some users, like Scrumptious_Foreskin, expressed doubts about the burger’s classification, stating, ‘Looks delicious but idk if I’d consider it a smash burger.’ Others, such as BHamm707, were more direct in their disagreement, bluntly stating, ‘This is not a smash burger.’

Size Matters

One user, Toastierbrush50, shared a helpful tip, suggesting, ‘Smash burgers are flat my dude. Still looks good tho, if I were you I would take a smaller size of your meat and just make it a double.’

The discussion continued with users like SauceHankRedemption calling for ‘more oomf’ in the smash, while gdubh humorously questioned, ‘Hulk no smash?’

In a surprising turn of events, pkragthorpe, the original poster, admitted, ‘It’s clear to me now that I need smaller patties to do a proper smash burger.’

Is It Really a Smash Burger?

While opinions varied, it was unanimous that the burger met accolades for its taste, despite the ongoing debate. As user JackBauersGhost quipped, ‘Sir that’s a standard cheeseburger… Smash burgers need to be smashed lol.’

Ultimately, the community showcased a blend of humor, expertise, and culinary passion in dissecting this burger debacle, proving that the love for food transcends definitions and labels.