10 Ways to Make Your PB&J Sandwich More Exciting

Looking to spice up your PB&J sandwich? Check out these creative ideas from Reddit users!

Looking to elevate your simple PB&J sandwich? Reddit users shared their creative twists to make this classic more exciting. From grilled PB&J to adding unlikely ingredients, these hacks will take your sandwich game to the next level. Let’s dive in!


  • Grilled PB&J or PB & honey are fantastic alternatives.
  • Mix peanut butter and jelly together for a unique flavor.
  • Try adding ingredients like sliced bananas, cinnamon, or even bacon for a flavorful twist.

Grilled PB&J

One popular suggestion was to toast the PB&J like a grilled cheese sandwich. The user found this method to be a game-changer in elevating the sandwich’s taste and texture.

Mixing Peanut Butter and Jelly

One Redditor suggested thoroughly mixing the peanut butter and jelly before spreading it on the bread. This technique resulted in a completely different flavor profile, transforming the traditional PB&J experience.

Creative Ingredient Additions

Users recommended adding ingredients like sliced bananas, cinnamon, mushrooms, saltines, peanuts, and even salty chips between the bread slices to enhance the sandwich’s taste and texture. Some users went as far as combining peanut butter with cream cheese or cheese slices for a unique twist.

One user recommended deep-frying the sandwich, adding bacon, and using honey or strawberry preserves with devil’s food cake icing for a decadent treat. Another suggested a combination of peanut butter, honey, sunflower seeds, and pepitas on dark bread for a flavorful and nutritious option.

For those looking for a sweet touch, adding maple syrup to a mix of peanut butter, cinnamon, and French toast was a hit among users. Not to forget, using a waffle iron to toast the sandwich was also labeled a must-try.

Whether you prefer a classic PB&J or are open to experimenting with unconventional additions, these creative ideas from Reddit users are sure to add excitement to your sandwich routine. With these hacks, your PB&J sandwich will never be the same!